I think Not! Live

Get ready for a hilarious night of true crime and musical theater mayhem as Ellyn Marsh and Joey Taranto bring their hit podcast I Think Not! to the stage! Known for their outrageous chemistry and love of all things dramatic, Ellyn and Joey will be recapping an episode of a fan-favorite true crime TV show — complete with Broadway flair, comedic twists, and plenty of surprises.

Both seasoned Broadway performers (from Kinky Boots, Rock of Ages, Pretty Woman, and more), Ellyn and Joey have taken their talents offstage and into the podcast world, creating a cult following with their blend of dark humor, pop culture references, and genuine heart.

Whether you're a true crime junkie, theater nerd, or just love to laugh, this live show promises a one-of-a-kind night you won't forget.